Red Velvet Cake Frosting: Cream Cheese vs. Buttercream

Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake remains to be one of the most popular and well-known cakes, characterized by a deep red color and delicious texture. The frosting used for the red velvet cake design is one of its essential features, and people loved it. For example, there are people who prefer cream cheese frosting, while others are more inclined to buttercream frosting. Below, we will discuss the difference between two types of frosting, which will help you choose which one is the best for your next red velvet cake.

Cream Cheese Frosting

It is quite customary to pair red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting, which is also seen as perfect. This creamy, sour icing is a perfect match to the cake, as it gently amplifies the chocolate taste.

The Ingredients in Cream Cheese Frosting

Cream cheese frosting is made by using ingredients such as cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, and vanilla extract. The cream cheese brings more of a hint of tang to the biscuits, and the butter gives them moistness and depth. The frosting is sweetened using powdered sugar and also flavored with vanilla extract.

Texture of Cream Cheese Frosting

Cream cheese frosting is one of the richest frostings as it gives cakes that smooth and velvety texture on the surface. The main advantage of the powder form is that it holds reliably steady and is suitable for applying thick layers of frosting which are enjoyed by many.

Cream Cheese Frosting Characteristics

In the red velvet cake, the cream cheese frosting has a slightly tangy taste to counter the sweetness of the cake. It creates a balance of all the required ingredients, which makes it a preferred choice for many cake lovers.

Making Cream Cheese Frosting

For the preparation of cream cheese frosting, first, use cream cheese and butter at room temperature and blend until creamy. Begin incorporating powdered sugar and vanilla slowly until the frosting is smooth and fluffy. One important thing that needs to be done is to make sure that all ingredients used are brought to room temperature to give a good blend.

Buttercream Frosting

Another traditional option for red velvet cake is buttercream frosting. This type of icing is delicious, creamy, and made of butter and sugar. It can be American, Swiss, or Italian buttercream.

The Texture of Buttercream Frosting

What makes buttercream even more versatile is that it is smooth and fluffy and can be piped or spread over the cake. Its thickness can be easily modified by adding more milk or cream, making it ideal for a number of decorating tasks.

The Flavor Profile of Buttercream Frosting

Another great characteristic of buttercream frosting is its sweet and buttery-like taste that complements the delicate chocolate taste of the red velvet cake. This can be flavored in various ways, which can create variety when it comes to cake making.

Making Buttercream Frosting

First, to prepare buttercream frosting, allow the butter to soften and beat it until creamy. Slowly incorporate the powdered sugar, milk, cream, and vanilla extract and continue blending until the mixture becomes fluffy. To thin the ganache, add more milk, or for thickening, add more powdered sugar.

Cream Cheese vs. Buttercream: A Comparison

When deciding between cream cheese and buttercream frosting for your red velvet cake, consider the following factors: the choice could be based on factors such as taste, texture, the process of preparation, and individual preferences.

Flavor Comparison

The cream cheese frosting is particularly nice because it imparts a slightly sour note that complements the cake’s considerable sweetness. Buttercream frosting, in particular, boasts a buttery and sweet taste. Your decision may depend on whether you are planning to have a tangy or simply a sweet frosting.

Texture Comparison

Cream cheese frosting is less moist than buttercream frosting, making it suitable for applying rich layers of frosting. The cream frosting is fluffy and moist, which is good for designs and other fancy work on the cake. When selecting the frosting to use, keep in mind the texture you want for your cake.

Ease of Making

Both frostings are not very complicated and can be prepared in a relatively short time, but when making cream cheese frosting, all the ingredients should be softened to ensure that they blend well. It is discovered that buttercream made from powdered sugar is not very sensitive to temperature, which makes this frosting slightly easier than icing sugar for a beginner.

Storage and Stability

Cream cheese frosting should be refrigerated. Any dairy products must not be stored and used at room temperature because they go bad quickly. It is also more fitting for outdoor events or warm climates since buttercream frosting can be left out at room temperature for quite a while.

Popularity and Tradition

The best frosting for red velvet cake is cream cheese, and this kind of frosting is usually recommended for this cake type. Yet, buttercream frosting, which is commonly applied in online cake delivery, has received considerable attention because it is highly flexible and less sensitive to storage conditions.


The way of choosing the frosting is based on flavor, texture, easy manner of preparation, and the kind of frosting that everybody likes. Cream cheese frosting is traditional and gives a tangy accent to complement the red velvet cake, while buttercream frosting is suitable for a wide range of occasions and tastes buttery. Both have benefits, so it might be useful to switch between them in order to find out which one you like more. Whether you go with tradition or choose versatility, both frostings will undoubtedly improve the taste of the red velvet cake.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *